Answer in brief

General rulings on hajj and umrah

Are pilgrims allowed to practise talfiq, combining the views of different schools of thought, when performing Hajj rulings?

Answer in brief

According to the resolution of the 41st National Hajj Deliberation, talfiq in the rulings of Hajj rites applies in only two situations. The first is when the Shafi'i school holds no view on the matter. The second is when a Shafi'i view exists but conflicts with the public interest (maslahah ‘ammah) or with a decision of the authorities.1

Summary written by DHUMY from the Malay original and checked against it.

From the resolution (Malay original)

Aplikasi talfiq dalam hukum-hakam Ibadat haji hanya terpakai sekiranya tiada pandangan dalam mazhab Syafie atau jika ada, ia berlawanan dengan kepentingan awam (maslahah 'ammah) atau bertentangan dengan keputusan pihak berkuasa.

Source

Resolusi Muzakarah Haji Peringkat Kebangsaan ke-41 (Musim Haji 1446H/2024M), Kertas Kerja 3: Masalah Talfiq (Percampuran/Penggabungan Mazhab) Dalam Pelaksanaan Hukum Haji, resolusi 10Lembaga Tabung Haji (Pilgrims Fund Board) · National Hajj Muzakarah resolutions · Published 29 September 2024

A newer resolution overrides an older one on the same working paper. Full working papers are available from the Hajj Guidance Division of Tabung Haji.

Read the full resolution (Malay PDF) →

This page summarises a published fatwa; it is not a new ruling. For your own situation, read the full fatwa or consult the mufti office of your state.

Other questions on this topic

All fatwa references →

Related guides

Ask another question →