Answer in brief

Tawaf

Does accidental touching between a man and a woman during tawaf invalidate wudu, and is the tawaf still valid?

Answer in brief

Wudu is a condition for a valid tawaf. The preferred view in the Shafi'i school holds that skin contact between a man and a woman without a barrier breaks wudu, while the Hanafi school holds that it does not, and the well-known Hanbali and Maliki view is that it does not break wudu if there is no desire. This fatwa follows the 21st Hajj Muzakarah, which permits adopting the weaker Shafi'i opinion that wudu remains valid when contact occurs without desire in situations of hardship such as crowding during tawaf. The wudu is therefore not invalidated and the tawaf remains valid.

Summary written by DHUMY from the Malay original and checked against it.

From the fatwa (Malay original)

Oleh itu, kami menyatakan sepertimana yang telah diputuskan oleh Muzakarah Haji ke-21 iaitu wudhu' tidak terbatal berdasarkan pendapat mazhab Syafi'e yang marjuh dan ianya juga bertepatan dengan mazhab Hanbali dan juga Maliki. Maka, sah juga tawafnya kerana wudhu' tidak terbatal.

Source

AL-KAFI #421 : BERSENTUHAN ANTARA LELAKI DAN WANITA KETIKA TAWAF, ADAKAH MEMBATALKAN WUDHU’?Office of the Mufti of the Federal Territories · Al-Kafi li al-Fatawi · Published 2 November 2016

Read the full fatwa (Malay) →

This page summarises a published fatwa; it is not a new ruling. For your own situation, read the full fatwa or consult the mufti office of your state.

Other questions on this topic

All fatwa references →

Related guides